Can TikTok Comments Actually Replace Therapy?
No, TikTok comments can’t replace therapy, but they’re not nothing either. They give you something real: a sense that you’re not the only one, at an hour when nobody else is around to say it. The problem is what that comfort can’t do, and where it quietly runs out.
Video embed placeholder
Why the Comments Feel More Honest Than the Video
In my practice, when a client brings up TikTok, they rarely bring it up as something to feel silly about. They bring it up as the first time in weeks someone put words to what they’d been carrying. At 1am, a comment section full of ‘me too’ can feel more honest than the video sitting above it. That’s not a character flaw, and it’s not proof you’re chronically online. It’s your mind doing something sensible: looking for evidence that what you’re feeling has a name, and that you’re not the only one holding it.
The Riskiest Content Is Winning the Algorithm
Here’s where it gets uncomfortable. A 2026 study of TikTok videos on ADHD and mental health found a genuine ‘quality-engagement paradox’: clips flagged as higher risk for encouraging self-diagnosis picked up significantly more likes and shares than accurate, professionally made content, while quality itself had no real relationship to how much a video was engaged with (Yu et al., 2026, Digital Health, DOI: 10.1177/20552076261434141). In plain terms, the app is not rewarding the videos most likely to help you. It’s rewarding the ones most likely to convince you something’s wrong.
Clinicians and Young Adults Don’t Read the Same Videos the Same Way
This gap shows up in how people actually use the content, too. Research comparing mental health professionals with young adults found the two groups disagreed on how educational TikTok’s ADHD content really is, and that watching it was linked to young adults estimating a higher prevalence of ADHD and imagining greater challenges for people who have it than clinicians thought was warranted (Karasavva et al., 2025, PLOS ONE, DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0319335). Neither group is wrong to be looking. They’re just weighing the same fifteen seconds very differently.
What the Research Actually Says About Online Support
It’s tempting to assume comment-section support is basically therapy for free. A large meta-analysis pooling 32 studies and over 10,000 participants found online social support interventions produced no significant improvement in psychological wellbeing overall, once you looked past the individual studies that happened to show a positive result (Liu et al., 2025, Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being, DOI: 10.1111/aphw.70090). What mattered more than the platform was who was actually providing the support, and whether it fit the person receiving it. A comment thread is not automatically the same thing as care.
What a Comment Section Can’t Do
Comments are static. They can’t ask what’s underneath the thing you just said, and they can’t notice that your tone has changed over the last three posts. They don’t track whether you’re getting better or worse across a month, and they can’t tell the difference between a genuinely hard week and something that needs more than encouragement. That gap is worth being honest about, because the videos most likely to keep you scrolling are, per the research above, often the least equipped to help you close it.
Let the Comments Be Company, Not the Whole Plan
None of this means you should feel embarrassed for reading them. Finding relief in ‘me too’ is a completely reasonable response to feeling alone with something. Where it's worth pausing is if the comments have become the only place you take your feelings, especially if things aren't actually improving. Online therapy exists precisely for people who want something that starts as low-effort as scrolling but goes further than a stranger's comment ever could.
Related reading
Have you ever found more comfort in a comment section than in your own life?
Are you considering starting therapy? Find your perfect counsellor today.
Start Therapy Today
Browse our therapists and connect with the right person to start your journey with - from today.
- All therapists listed are fully vetted
- Dedicated, passionate and honest
- Ready to take that first step with you